SEO Then vs. Now: What Changed & What’s Better?

SEO has come a long way in the last decade. What once worked to get a website ranked on Google can now lead to penalties, and strategies that were unheard of ten years ago are now essential. As search engines have become more advanced, SEO has shifted from stuffing keywords and chasing backlinks to focusing on user experience, content quality, and technical performance.

In this article, we’ll break down the biggest differences between SEO in 2015 and today, discuss what worked better in the past, what’s improved now, and what businesses need to do to stay ahead in 2025.

‍

How SEO Has Changed Over the Last Decade

‍

1. Keywords: Exact Match vs. Intent-Based Search

Then (2015): SEO was all about keywords—specifically, exact-match keywords. The more times a phrase appeared on a page, the better it was expected to rank. Websites would often overuse keywords, even at the cost of readability. Meta tags were also loaded with keywords in hopes of boosting rankings.

Example of 2015 SEO Content:

“Looking for the best running shoes? Our guide to the best running shoes will help you find the best running shoes for men, the best running shoes for women, and the best running shoes for kids.”

‍

Now (2025): Google no longer relies on exact-match keywords alone. Instead, search engines use AI-driven models like RankBrain and BERT to understand search intent and context. This means that content needs to be written in a natural, engaging way that answers users’ questions rather than just repeating keywords.

Example of 2025 SEO Content:

“Choosing the right running shoes depends on factors like your foot type, gait, and activity level. In this guide, we’ll explore the best options for different needs and budgets.”

‍

What’s Better Now:

• Google understands synonyms, intent, and user queries, making content more natural and user-friendly.
• Well-written, informative content performs better than keyword-heavy pages.

What Was Better Then:

• Websites could rank quickly by stuffing keywords without much regard for content quality.

‍

2. Backlinks: Quantity vs. Quality

Then (2015): The more backlinks a site had, the higher it ranked—regardless of the source. Many websites participated in link farms, bought backlinks, and spammed blog comments to increase their rankings.

Now (2025): Google’s Penguin algorithm update changed the game. Today, quality matters far more than quantity. A few high-authority, relevant backlinks can be far more effective than hundreds of spammy ones. Websites must now focus on earning links naturally through valuable content and strong relationships.

‍

What’s Better Now:

• ‍Higher-quality links mean more trustworthy search results.
• Spammy, low-value websites no longer dominate rankings.

What Was Better Then:

• It was easier to manipulate rankings by buying backlinks or using automated tools.

‍

3. Mobile Optimization: A Bonus vs. A Requirement

Then (2015): Websites were primarily designed for desktop users. Mobile versions were an afterthought, and mobile usability had little impact on rankings.

Now (2025): Mobile-first indexing is the standard. Google ranks websites based on their mobile version, meaning that sites need to be fully optimized for smaller screens, touch interactions, and fast loading speeds.

‍

What’s Better Now:

• ‍Better mobile experiences for users.
• Websites are faster and more accessible across all devices.

What Was Better Then:

• Websites were simpler and didn’t require as much mobile-specific optimization

‍

4. Content: Short & Keyword-Heavy vs. Long-Form & Valuable

Then (2015): SEO content was often short (300-500 words), repetitive, and stuffed with keywords. Many articles were written purely to rank rather than to provide useful information.

Now (2025): Long-form, high-quality content (1,500+ words) ranks better because Google prioritizes expertise, authority, and trust (E-A-T). Articles that offer real value, backed by research and credible sources, tend to perform best.

‍

What’s Better Now:

• More informative and engaging content for readers.‍
• Higher trust and authority for well-researched articles.

What Was Better Then:

• It was easier to rank with shorter, less detailed articles.

‍

5. Technical SEO: Basic vs. Advanced

Then (2015): Technical SEO was important, but relatively simple. The main focus was on meta tags, XML sitemaps, and clean URLs.

Now (2025): Technical SEO has become much more advanced. Page speed, Core Web Vitals, structured data (schema markup), AI-driven enhancements, and security (HTTPS) all play a major role in rankings.

‍

What’s Better Now:

• ‍Faster, more secure websites that offer better user experiences.
• Search engines better understand content, entities, and context with structured data.
  

What Was Better Then:

• ‍Less technical complexity meant SEO was easier to implement.

‍

What This Means for Businesses Using Webflow

If you’re using Webflow to build your website, you’re already in a strong position to succeed in modern SEO. Webflow’s clean code, fast hosting, built-in SEO tools, and mobile responsiveness make it easier to optimize your site for today’s search engine requirements.

‍

To stay competitive in 2025:

1. ‍Create high-quality, user-focused content rather than chasing keywords.‍
2. Earn backlinks naturally by publishing valuable resources and building relationships.‍
3. Optimize for mobile-first indexing, which Webflow simplifies with its responsive design.‍
4. Leverage schema markup and Core Web Vitals for better rankings.‍
5. Track performance using Google Search Console & Analytics to adapt to SEO changes.

‍

Final Thoughts

SEO has evolved from a game of shortcuts and loopholes to a long-term strategy based on user experience, content quality, and technical optimization. While ranking was easier 10 years ago, today’s approach ensures better, more relevant search results for users.

Businesses using Webflow or other modern platforms have more tools than ever to optimize their sites effectively. The key to success in 2025? Stay adaptable, focus on providing value, and keep up with Google’s evolving algorithms.